Morality and faith: in detail wed, violently antagonistic, or whatever else? dialogue of this factor appears to be like in popular culture, the academy, and the media―often producing significantly adversarial perspectives. At one finish of the spectrum are those that imagine that until God exists, ethics is unfounded and the ethical lifestyles is unmotivated. on the different finish are those that imagine that spiritual trust is senseless for―and even a hazard to―ethical wisdom and the ethical life.

This quantity offers an available, charitable dialogue that represents more than a few perspectives alongside this spectrum. The booklet starts off with a full of life debate among Paul Kurtz and William Lane Craig at the query, Is goodness with no God more than enough? Kurtz defends the affirmative place and Craig the destructive. Following the controversy are new essays by way of famous students. those essays touch upon the controversy and boost the wider dialogue of faith and morality. The e-book closes with ultimate responses from Kurtz and Craig.

Show description

Read Online or Download Is Goodness without God Good Enough?: A Debate on Faith, Secularism, and Ethics PDF

Best Ethics books

The Right To Be Loved

S. Matthew Liao argues the following that youngsters have a correct to be enjoyed. to take action he investigates questions equivalent to no matter if youngsters are rightholders; what grounds a kid's correct to liked; no matter if love is a suitable item of a correct; and different philosophical and functional matters. His idea is that every one humans have rights to the elemental stipulations for pursuing an outstanding lifestyles; accordingly, as people, little ones have human rights to the elemental stipulations for pursuing an outstanding lifestyles.

Kantian Consequentialism

The primary challenge for normative ethics is the clash among a consequentialist view--that morality calls for selling the great of all--and a trust that the rights of the person position major constraints on what might be performed to assist others. normal interpretations see Kant as rejecting all types of consequentialism, and protecting a idea that's essentially duty-based and agent-centered.

Divine Commands and Moral Requirements (Clarendon Library of Logic and Philosophy)

During this wide-ranging research, Quinn argues that human ethical autonomy is appropriate with unqualified obedience to divine instructions. He formulates a number of models of the an important assumptions of divine command ethics, protecting them opposed to a battery of objections frequently expressed within the philosophical literature.

British Ethical Theorists from Sidgwick to Ewing (The Oxford History of Philosophy)

Thomas Hurka provides the 1st complete old learn of an enormous strand within the improvement of contemporary ethical philosophy. His topic is a sequence of British moral theorists from the past due 19th century to the mid-twentieth century, who shared key assumptions that made them a unified and particular tuition.

Additional resources for Is Goodness without God Good Enough?: A Debate on Faith, Secularism, and Ethics

Show sample text content

NOTES 1. See Edward J. Larson and Larry Witham, “Leading Scientists nonetheless Reject God,” Nature, 23 July 1998,313. 2. American spiritual identity Survey: 2001. Graduate heart of town college of recent York. on hand on-line at www. gc. cuny. edu/faculty/research_ briefs/aris/key_findings. htm. three. foreign Social Survey application: faith II, ICPSR, Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1998. on hand on-line at www. prod. library. utoronto. ca:8090/datalib/codebooks/ icpsr/3065/cb3065. pdf. four. Paul Kurtz, The braveness to turn into (Westport, Conn. : Praeger, 1997). five. Kurtz, braveness to turn into, one hundred twenty five. 6. Kurtz, braveness to develop into, 5–6. 7. Kurtz, braveness to turn into, 6. eight. Kurtz, braveness to develop into, fifty three. nine. Michael Ruse, “Evolutionary concept and Christian Ethics,” within the Darwinian Paradigm (London: Routledge, 1989), 262, 268–69. 10. Paul Kurtz, Forbidden Fruit (Buffalo, N. Y. : Prometheus Books, 1988), seventy three. eleven. Richard Taylor, Ethics, religion, and cause (Englewood Cliffs, N. J. : PrenticeHall, 1985), 14. 12. Taylor, Ethics, religion, and cause, 83–84. thirteen. Kurtz, braveness to turn into, 27–28. 14. Fyodor Dostoyevsky, The Brothers Karamazov, trans. C. Garnett (New York: Signet Classics, 1957), bk. 2, chap. 6; bk. five, chap. four; bk. 1, chap. eight. 15. R. Z. Friedman, “Does the ‘Death of God’ actually matter? ” overseas Philosophical Quarterly 23 (1983): 322. sixteen. Kurtz, Forbidden Fruit, sixty five. 17. Kurtz, braveness to turn into, 17. 18. Kurtz, Forbidden Fruit, eighty. 19. serious realize of Peter Haas, Morality after Auschwitz: the unconventional problem of the Nazi Ethic (Philadelphia: citadel Press, 1988), via R. L. Rubenstein, magazine of the yankee Academy of faith 60 (Spring 1992): 158. 20. Massimo Pigliucci, “Does the Christian God Exist? ” debate with William Lane Craig, college of Georgia, 22 March 2001. Professor Pigliucci now says, “If you'll quote me—I wouldn’t say that morality is ‘an invention’ of people, fairly that it's a organic phenomenon that applies purely to sentient social animals, resembling people” (personal correspondence, 1 June 2007). 21. unswerving D. Rue, “The Saving Grace of Noble Lies,” handle to the yankee Academy for the development of technological know-how, February 1991. 22. Kurtz, braveness to turn into, 15. half II NEW ESSAYS bankruptcy an ethical Argument for the lifestyles of God C. Stephen Layman Dr. Craig defends conditional theses referring to God and morality: (1) if theism is correct, we've a valid origin for morality; and (2) if theism is fake, we don't have a valid origin for morality. he's correct, after all, in watching that such conditional theses may be actual whether their if-clauses are fake. yet i need to invite the additional query no matter if our universal ideals approximately morality truly do supply any aid for theism. i'm going to argue that they do; that's, i'm going to supply an ethical argument for the lifestyles of God. sooner than I set forth my argument, a sequence of initial reviews is so as. First, in my view, just a cumulative-case method of the problem of God’s life has an opportunity of delivering stable grounds for believing that God exists.

Rated 4.36 of 5 – based on 24 votes