By Michael J. Gerhardt

The position that precedent performs in constitutional determination making is a perennially divisive topic between students of legislation and American politics. the talk rages over either empirical and normative facets of the difficulty: To what quantity are the best courtroom, Congress, and the administrative department limited by means of precedent? To what quantity should still they be? taking on an issue lengthy past due for complete therapy, Michael Gerhardt connects the great social technological know-how info and felony scholarship to supply the main wide-ranging overview of precedent in numerous a long time.

Updated to mirror contemporary felony circumstances, The energy of Precedent clearly outlines the key concerns within the carrying on with debates at the value of precedent and flippantly considers either side. For the excellent court docket, precedents take many types, together with not just the Court's prior reviews, but additionally norms, historic practices, and traditions that the justices have intentionally selected to persist with. In those varieties, precedent exerts extra strength than is usually said. This strength is encapsulated within the implementation and popularity of what Gerhardt calls the "golden rule of precedent," an immense dynamic in constitutional legislations. the rule of thumb calls upon justices and different public specialists to acknowledge that considering they anticipate others to recognize their very own precedents, they have to give you the related recognize to others' precedents. Gerhardt's wide exploration of precedent leads him to formulate a extra expansive definition of it, person who encompasses not just the previous constitutional judgements of courts but in addition the constitutional judgments of alternative public gurus. Gerhardt concludes his examine by way of taking a look at what the long run holds for the concept that, as he examines the selections and attitudes towards precedent exhibited by way of the shift from the Rehnquist to the Roberts Court.

Authoritative and incisive, Gerhardt provides an in-depth examine this important but understudied phenomenon on the middle of all constitutional conflicts and one in every of indisputable value to American legislation and politics. eventually, The energy of Precedent vividly illustrates how constitutional legislations is made and evolves either in and out of doors of the courts.

Show description

Read or Download The Power of Precedent PDF

Similar Constitutional Law books

Unequal: How America's Courts Undermine Discrimination Law (Law and Current Events Masters)

It's no mystery that because the Eighties, American employees have misplaced energy vis-à-vis employers. besides the well-chronicled steep decline in inner most zone unionization, American staff alleging employment discrimination have fared more and more poorly within the courts. lately, judges have pushed aside ratings of circumstances during which employees provided facts that supervisors observed them utilizing racial or gender slurs.

The Constitution and the Pride of Reason

Trying to notice Plato's imaginative and prescient of a republic ruled by means of "reason," American constitutionalists, in keeping with Steven D. Smith's daring new serious learn, have as a substitute reenacted the Tower of Babel fantasy, generating a constitutional discourse marked by means of rampant confusion, complex sophistry, and thinly veiled authoritarian bullying.

The Law Market

This day, a California resident can contain her delivery enterprise in Delaware, check in her ships in Panama, rent her staff from Hong Kong, position her gains in an asset-protection belief shaped within the Cayman Islands, and input right into a same-sex marriage in Massachusetts or Canada--all the whereas having fun with the California sunshine and probably averting many features of the state's legislation.

After Public Law (Oxford Constitutional Theory)

Public legislation has been conceived in lots of alternative ways, occasionally overlapping, frequently conflicting. even though lately a typical subject matter operating during the discussions of public legislation is one in every of loss. What functionality and destiny can public legislation have during this swiftly remodeling panorama, the place globalized states and supranational associations have ever-increasing value?

Extra info for The Power of Precedent

Show sample text content

Rated 4.48 of 5 – based on 33 votes